car stereo wars: hip hop halloween monster mash-up
even though i still love halloween (and still get dressed up, obvs), i do miss trick or treating. the neighborhood streets i knew so well were transformed into a magical and eerie place, where little people like me frolicked and giggled and shrieked and filled our bags with sugary surprises. back then, i felt like we *owned* the streets, and the adults were just lucky to be there. we all knew the houses that gave away whole candy bars (WHOLE BARS!) and the houses that always gave you the crappy hard gum. the darkened houses were always the most mysterious to me… black, blank spaces between the homes with porch lights and grinning jack o’ lanterns.
even though i’m way too old for trick or treating, i still think about candy a lot (duh). so today, as i walked down memory lane, i decided to make a list of the best and grosses halloween candy of all time. please join me on this caloric tour of delights (and horror), and then feel free to leave yr own suggestions and candy memories in the comments.
first, the good stuff.
if i came home with at least four reese’s peanut butter cups (and i’m talking the real size, not the minis), i knew i was in business.

reese’s was (and still is) the best candy in the world. often i would hoard my peanut butter cups because i wanted to make them last as long as possible, and then, four months later, they would develop that weird light white film on top and i knew they were dead to me. DEAD.
actually, this happened to me a lot. one, cos i was an only child, so i didn’t have to worry about someone else eating my candy. two, cos i actually liked *looking* at my candy more than eating it (which is still true today. i keep cadbury eggs around FOREVER, just ask henri).
my second favorite candy was the all american classic, snickers.

even the fun size is so satisfying!!!!!
third on my list, and extremely rare, were wax lips.

i know, wax lips aren’t “candy” per se. but they are SO FUN!!!!! you can put them on yr lips and look goofy and make people laugh, and then you can kind of chew on them, which is gross but oddly enjoyable. and it is sort of like wearing lipstick, which i was not allowed to do at the age of 7, which made the lips even more alluring.
i also loved any of the hershey’s collection and those sweet little boxes of nerds. NERDS! so colorful and crunchy!

ok, let’s move on to the crappy candy.
the BANE of halloween’s existence is, of course, the box of raisins.

there’s nothing worse than dumping yr big bag o’ candy on the living room floor and discovering the taunting face of the sun maid raisin girl. i HATE her. she’s all, “i’m so cheerful and sunny and i’ve brought you a healthy snack instead of all of that sugar and fat!”
to this day, i still don’t like raisins. so suck it, sun maid.
next, necco wafers.

you know, back in college, i actually visited the necco factory in boston with becky. i thought maybe seeing the factory would explain to me why necco wafers actually exist as a candy. what candy niche do they *possibly* fill? oh, the tasteless, pastel, chalky niche? good to know.
now let’s talk about two types of candy that i was never able to actually understand as a kid. these things:

and chick-o-sticks:

turns out they both come from the atkinson candy factory in lufkin, texas (sorry, meredith). but what ARE they, exactly? the top items are called crunchy peanut butter bars, but hello, if they were peanut butter, wouldn’t they LOOK like peanut butter? they don’t! they are white and striped and kinda remind me of a cool eraser i had in the second grade. as for chick-o-sticks, like, WTF? there isn’t even a stick involved!! and if there’s a BABY CHICKEN involved, i don’t even want to know. all i DO know is that these two candies usually represented about 1/5 of my entire candy net of the night. and guess what? weird peanut butter bars don’t get you SQUAT during the end-of-the-night candy trade.
on similar lines, the one candy that i could never identify, even after YEARS of trick or treat experience, were these things:

turns out that they are peanut butter taffy. again, i ask you, do they look like peanut butter? no. attention, homeowners: if you want to buy something peanut buttery, is there any other choice than reese’s? cos if you buy this taffy stuff, i guarantee this will happen to every single piece:
[end of the night, kid sorting through candy]
kid: let’s see… let’s see… YES! i got three butterfingers! sweet! and a role of life savers! and… wait. what is THIS? it’s wrapped in black wax paper! and there’s no label! and it’s all brown and mushy inside. uh… it’s probably poison. or poop.
[dumps all 45 pieces of it in the trash]
end scene.
if you’re too cheap to buy candy with actual labels, just don’t bother turning yr porch light on, ok, SCROOGE?
and, last but not least, the worst thing to see in yr candy bag: a toothbrush.

i HATED the people who gave away toothbrushes. they were always so smug and self-righteous, like, “oh, hellooo, widdle children! you’re going to rot yr precious teeth out with all of that candy, so i’m going to teach you a Life Lesson by giving you a toothbrush instead of a snickers bar! and it’s a Cool Neon Color, just so you know that brushing yr teeth can be super neat-o!”
UGH. i hope the great pumpkin comes over and PUNCHES YOU IN THE FACE.
i now want to take a second to talk about nasty candy. i don’t mean bad-tasting, i mean CREEPY. when i was a kid, the ickiest candy you could find were probably gummy spiders or something. now, there’s like the “saw IV” candy market. check out these oozing eyeballs:

sure, they look innocuous. but watch this video (scroll down about halfway) to understand their heebie jeebie potential.
GAH!!!! i am so creeped out!!!
even grosser? EAR WAX CANDY. no, i am not kidding.
check this out, care of candy addict:

since i don’t want to end this post on an icky note, here are two “scary” CUPCAKES, care of design*sponge:


i admit, the eyes freak me out. but i would so totally still eat it.
HAPPY HALLOWEEN, EVERYBODY! i hope you eat lots of candy and successfully avoid any encounters with raisins or peanut butter taffy.
















You would totally not eat the eyeball cupcake, Sarah. You would look at it for a month, yes. But eventually I would have to come over to eat it, just like those mellow creme pumpkins. What’ve you had, like 3? I’ve eaten 50!
Can you get some gummy colas for November, please? Those were and are my favorite candy. Number 2 on the list are those funky tootsie rolls that aren’t chocolate flavored but are instead cherry or yellow or something. Those were always my favorite Halloween candies because I could never find them anywhere on my own. Reese’s are great, sure, but if I was jonesing for one I could just go to Winn’s and get one. Fruity tootsie rolls? I think one of the parents in my neighborhood made them himself, and they’re so tasty and good.
All in all, though, candy was good and everything, but I still prefer Halloween as an adult, when it’s filled with alcohol instead. I just wish I could go around to my neighbors houses now and they’d all give me tiny little airplane bottles of Jameson. That would be amazing, and we should start that tradition somehow.
we always had to go through our candy and throw away things like that taffy, because it always came half-unwrapped, and mama didn’t let us eat no half-wrapped candy.
do not forget skittles and starburst, my faves. the little packages of starburst were kinda cute. spree, kinda lame.
Absolute favorite halloween candy right now is Sweet Tart Chews… they are a combination of laffy taffy and sweet tart. Awesome. You can only get them in mix bags… They need to sell them in a bag all by their own since We fight over them at our house.
Oh man, I remember when those sweet tart chews came out. Kids in my school went nutso for them. I always got confused by the explosion of flavors that made my tongue feel like a Vietnam vet having flashbacks.
Oh man..Halloween candy. How do you decide your favorites. I always traded anything for M&Ms..my fav at the time. And although like Henri pointed out, I can get them anywhere..it was so much more enjoyable if they were handed to me by a stranger.
I had a very fortunate childhood cause our next door neighbor gave out WHOLE CANDY BARS every single year. Then when their kids were older they used to let us trick or treat there late at night and would give us a whole bunch…I love them.
I remember the last time we went Trick-Or-Treating- it was our Pigbutt “Titantic” theme party. I remember Christine was the captain, Keriann the stowaway and Rachel the Iceburg. Everyone else is kind of a blur. But we had fun and put a lot of thought into it.
I don’t like candy all that much. I totally give mine away. My only prefered candy now is pretty much anything gummy. Especially gummy strawberries. Those are the best. Not so much given out at Halloween though.
L-Town repreSENT! Atkinson in the hizzouse! Also, I agree with Henri, although specifically the CHERRY gummy colas are where it’s truly at.
I never really enjoyed most candy except if it contained chocolate and PB. Like you Sarah, I could not and can not get enough Reese’s PB cups. The pieces run a close second, then Snickers…anything else was consumed just because it was halloween.
Candy corn still makes me nauseous.
There was a house on my street that always gave out change. Like, pennies, and maybe if you were lucky, a nickel. You’d get home, dump out your bag of awesome candy, and then at the bottom have like 4 stupid pennies. You suck, penny-giving neighbor!
Except I think they were diabetic and that’s why they didn’t have candy. Sorry I hated you when I was a kid, diabetic penny-giving neighbor. It’s not your fault. It’s not your fault. It’s not your fault.
Dude, Owen’s diabetic and he totally gave out lots and lots of candy last night. Bowls full of the stuff.
Still no Jameson bottles for the adults, though.
Henri, there are areas in Portland (or so the tale was told at the work potluck yesterday) where any adults trick-or-treating get shots (the alcoholic kind, not flu). Kids still get candy.
Also, by “those funky tootsie rolls that aren’t chocolate flavored”, do you mean Brach’s Royals?
We did a Top 10 List of Worst Non-Candy Halloween Treats last year. Rasins did make the list
Brian
Does the Great Pumpkin have arms?
i think henri means these: http://www.tootsie.com/fl_roll.html
todd, i hope you know that trend (trick or treat shots for adults) is alive and well in austin, as we discovered last night. which gives me one more reason to actually enjoying growing up.
randy, NO ONE KNOWS. cos the great pumpkin has NEVER BEEN SEEN. but you better believe that the great pumpkin will deliver judgment on any halloween haters.